Cooperation and Conflict in the Colonies


Cooperation and Conflict in the Colonies
Students learn that relationships between colonists and Indigenous peoples changed over time. They explore how early cooperation gave way to conflict as a result of growing tensions, shifting power, and broken agreements.

This learning experience is designed for device-enabled classrooms. The teacher guides the lesson, and students use embedded resources, social media skills, and critical thinking skills to actively participate. To get access to a free version of the complete lesson, sign up for an exploros account.

1:1 Devices
Teacher Pack

The Pack contains associated resources for the learning experience, typically in the form of articles and videos. There is a teacher Pack (with only teacher information) and a student Pack (which contains only student information). As a teacher, you can toggle between both to see everything.

Here are the teacher pack items for Cooperation and Conflict in the Colonies:

Preview - Scene 1
Exploros Learnign Experience Scene Navigation


Engage


Overview

In this experience, students examine the changing relationships between colonists and Indigenous people by evaluating examples of cooperation and conflict between the two groups. First, students identify the benefits each group gained by forming relationships at the time of contact. Then, they explore cooperation and conflict by discussing the causes and effects of shifting relationships at a broader level. Next, students analyze how Plymouth and Jamestown colonists interacted with Indigenous groups and explain how these examples reflect the evolving nature of colonial-Indigenous relationships across North America. Last, students examine the dominant narrative of the First Thanksgiving and discuss how it illustrates changes in the relationship between the two groups.

Estimated Duration: 45–60 minutes

Vocabulary:

  • agricultural expansion: the process of increasing the amount of land used for farming and raising livestock
  • hospitality: the friendly and generous treatment of guests, visitors, or strangers, often by welcoming them, sharing food or shelter, and making them feel comfortable
  • treaty: a formal, written agreement made between groups or nations, often created through negotiation, to keep peace, share resources, or solve problems

 

Objectives:

  • Explain how interactions between colonists and Indigenous peoples shaped the development of early North American colonies.
  • Describe how interactions between colonists and Indigenous peoples show changes in their relationships over time


When teaching history involving Indigenous communities, it is essential to understand that Indigenous peoples in North America are not a single group. They belong to hundreds of distinct nations, each with its own culture, government, language, and traditions. Because of this, not every Indigenous person identifies with every term associated with Indigenous people. Many Indigenous individuals today prefer to be identified by the name of their specific tribal nation, such as Wampanoag, Lakota, or Apache.

You may encounter various terms in historical sources or videos, including Indian, Native American, Indigenous American, or Indigenous person. These terms are not interchangeable, and each carries different histories, associations, and meanings.

This curriculum uses the term Indigenous person/people/group to reflect historical accuracy. This term recognizes the first peoples of North America without grouping them into a single identity.

To support students in this understanding, help them think critically about language, avoid generalizations, and approach this topic with care by providing historical context, modeling precise terminology, and encouraging respectful discussion.


During the colonization of North America, Europeans and the Indigenous groups living there came into contact for the first time and formed new relationships. These encounters were shaped by the choices each group made, the needs they had, and how they viewed one another.

In this lesson, you will trace the shifting relationships between colonists and Indigenous groups by exploring key events and turning points, and by identifying the causes and effects of those changes over time.

Objectives:

  • Explain how interactions between colonists and Indigenous peoples shaped the development of early North American colonies.
  • Describe how interactions between colonists and Indigenous peoples show changes in their relationships over time


This colorized historical illustration, titled "Interview of SAMOSET WITH THE PILGRIMS," depicts a Native American man, Samoset, shaking hands with a European Pilgrim. Samoset is adorned with a feathered headdress and traditional attire, while the Pilgrim wears a broad-brimmed hat and green jacket, with other figures and a distant ship in the background.

Interview of Samoset with the Pilgrims (Illustration 1)


This illustration, titled "Chamberlain and Paugus at Lovewell's Fight," depicts a dramatic one-on-one confrontation between an Indigenous warrior and a European frontiersman. Both figures are firing their muskets at close range, with smoke billowing from their weapons, amidst a natural setting.

Chamberlain and Paugus at Lovewell’s Fight (Illustration 2)


Evaluate the two illustrations above. Then, answer both discussion questions to explain what each illustration shows about the relationships between colonists and the Indigenous people of North America.

Challenge yourself to use at least two complete sentences in your responses. When you finish, add new details to a classmate’s response to support their answer further.


What does the image, Interview of Samoset with the Pilgrims (Illustration 1), show about the relationships between colonists and Indigenous populations in North America?
Use details from the illustration to support your answer.

Post your answer

What does the image, Chamberlain and Paugus at Lovewell’s Fight (Illustration 2), show about the relationships between colonists and Indigenous populations in North America?
Use details from the illustration to support your answer.

Post your answer

To support students in analyzing historical images, focus on guiding them to look closely, notice details, and ask questions about the source. Help students understand that historians use images as evidence because they offer insight into how people in the past viewed events, groups, and relationships. Images can reflect a creator’s perspective, purpose, and the values of the time.

These two illustrations show different moments of contact between colonists and Indigenous groups. Use this opportunity to prompt students to notice how the relationships are represented and how the illustrations suggest a change across time. Encourage students to support their ideas with specific visual evidence.

To guide discussion, consider asking:

  • What is different about how the two groups are interacting in each image?
  • What might these differences tell us about how the relationship changed over time?

 

This discussion helps prepare students for a deeper analysis of the causes and effects of those changing relationships in the scenes that follow.


When everyone is ready to continue, unlock the next scene.

End of Preview
The Complete List of Learning Experiences in Exploration and Colonization Unit.
Would you like to preview the rest of this learning experience, and get access to the entire functioning US History Through 1877 course for your classroom? Sign up using your school email address below.
Back to top